Jim Gillies( Certified Dog Behaviour Consultant )

Jim Gillies CDBC is a highly experienced and qualified dog behaviourist in Glasgow. With over a decade of experience working with dogs and their owners, Jim has earned a reputation as a trusted expert in his field. He is dedicated to promoting positive reinforcement and reward-based training techniques, always prioritising the well-being of the dogs he works with.

What is Errorless Learning?

Errorless learning is a method of teaching dogs that focuses on minimising the chances of a dog making errors during the learning process. In traditional training methods, dogs are often given the opportunity to make mistakes, which can lead to confusion and frustration for the dog, as well as a slower learning process. While it is true that animals can learn by making mistakes or by trial and error, it is not essential for their learning process.

The Goal of Errorless Learning

The goal of errorless learning is to create an environment where the dog can be successful from the very beginning. This is achieved by breaking down a behaviour into small, manageable steps, and rewarding the dog for each successful completion. By doing this, the dog is less likely to make mistakes, and therefore less likely to become frustrated or confused.

There are many benefits of errorless learning. It can help to create a positive learning environment for both the dog and the trainer. When dogs are successful, they are more likely to be motivated and engaged in the training process. This can lead to a more enjoyable experience for both the dog and the trainer, which can ultimately lead to better training outcomes. Implementing errorless learning in dog training can be done in several ways.

Benefits of Errorless Learning in Dogs:

There are many benefits to using errorless learning in dog training. One of the most significant benefits is that it can help dogs learn faster and more effectively. By eliminating errors and focusing on small, manageable steps, dogs can progress more quickly through the learning process. This can be particularly beneficial for dogs with behavioural issues, as it can help to build their confidence and reduce their anxiety.

1. Faster Learning: helps dogs learn faster because they are not making any mistakes.
2. Increased Confidence: By preventing dogs from making mistakes, they become more confident in their abilities and are more likely to succeed in future training sessions.
3. Reduced Stress: reduces stress for both the dog and the trainer because it eliminates the frustration that comes with making mistakes.
4. Improved Retention: Dogs are more likely to retain what they have learned through errorless learning because they have had successful experiences.

Implementing Errorless Learning:

1. Start with Basic Behaviours: Begin by teaching the dog simple behaviours that they are likely to succeed at, such as sit or come.
2. Break Down Complex Behaviours: For more complex behaviours, break them down into smaller steps and gradually increase the difficulty level.
3. Use Prompts: Use prompts to guide the dog towards the correct behaviour.
4. Reinforce Correct Behaviours: Always reinforce the correct behaviour with positive reinforcement.
5. Reduce Distractions: When starting a new behaviour, reduce distractions to increase the dog’s chances of success.
6. Practice Regularly: Regular practice is key to successful errorless learning.

Common Mistakes to Avoid:

1. Moving Too Quickly: It is important to take your time and not move too quickly when introducing new behaviors.
2. Using Negative Reinforcement: Negative reinforcement can be harmful to the learning process and should be avoided.
3. Failing to Reinforce Correct Behaviours: Always reinforce correct behaviours to encourage future success.
4. Not Reducing Distractions: Too many distractions can make it difficult for the dog to learn.

Errorless Learning Example for “Leave It”

1. Start Position: Begin with your dog in a stationary position in front of you. Hold a low-value treat in one hand and keep it stationary.
2. Reward Stationary Position: Initially, reward your dog for staying stationary without any attempt to take the treat. This reinforces the behaviour of remaining still.
3. Gradual Approach: Slowly move your treat-holding hand closer to your dog’s nose while ensuring they remain stationary.
4. Immediate Reward: As you move the treat closer, reward your dog’s stationary behaviour with a different high-value treat from your other hand. This reinforces the concept that staying still leads to rewards.
5. Repeat: Gradually decrease the distance between your hand with the treat and your dog’s nose. At each step, ensure your dog remains stationary before moving closer. Reward their stationary behaviour immediately each time.
6. Introduce Cue: Once your dog consistently remains stationary as you bring the treat close, introduce the cue “leave it” before presenting the low-value treat. Reward your dog when they successfully ignore the treat upon hearing the cue.
7. Practice: Practice this exercise regularly, gradually increasing the level of distraction and temptation. Always ensure that your dog starts from a stationary position and cannot make mistakes by grabbing the treat.

By starting with the end position (the dog remaining stationary) and gradually introducing the treat, you create an errorless learning environment where the dog is consistently rewarded for the desired behaviour without the opportunity to make mistakes. This method helps the dog associate “leave it” with staying still and not attempting to take the treat.

Exciting 2023 New Research on Errorless Learning in Dog Training

A recent study titled “Comparing trial-and-error to errorless learning procedures in training pet dogs a visual discrimination” by Kimberley Handley et al. examines errorless learning, a method that reduces incorrect responses in a stimulus discrimination task, and its effectiveness in dog training compared to trial-and-error methods.

Key Findings:

1. Methodology: Eight companion dogs were trained using either errorless learning (fading in an incorrect stimulus) or trial-and-error (reinforcing correct and incorrect responses). The study measured correct and incorrect responses, frustration-related responses, and non-responses.
2. Results: Dogs trained with errorless learning showed:
   • Higher likelihood of meeting learning criteria.
   • Faster acquisition of the task.
   • Fewer frustration-related behaviors compared to the trial-and-error group.
3. Implications: The study suggests that errorless learning is more effective and welfare-friendly for training dogs. This method could be more extensively used in canine training and research, highlighting its potential for improving dog training effectiveness and welfare.

Additional Insights:

• Errorless Learning Background: Originating from research on pigeons, this method minimizes errors by gradually introducing incorrect stimuli, thus reducing the opportunity for incorrect responses.
• Comparative Studies: Various species, including humans, have shown faster learning and fewer errors with errorless learning compared to trial-and-error methods. However, results vary depending on the task and method used.

Study’s Limitations and Future Directions:

• The study had a small sample size and limitations in experimental control due to non-laboratory settings.
• It suggests further research on errorless learning in dogs, especially concerning different stimuli (like scent or sound) and tasks, to enhance understanding and application in dog training.

In summary, this study supports the efficacy of errorless learning in dog training, showing it to be a more effective and welfare-conscious method compared to traditional trial-and-error approaches. This has important implications for dog trainers and owners seeking efficient and humane training methods.

If you find this article interesting, you might want to check out our blog and podcast section.

Enhancing Dog Training with Errorless Learning Techniques

Errorless learning is a powerful training technique that can help dogs learn faster, with more confidence, and less stress. By breaking down complex behaviours into smaller, manageable steps and reinforcing correct behaviours, trainers can help their dogs succeed and develop new skills.

When implemented correctly, errorless learning can be used to teach dogs of all ages and abilities a wide range of behaviours, from basic commands to more advanced tasks. By using positive reinforcement and avoiding common mistakes, trainers can create a supportive and effective learning environment for their dogs. Overall, errorless learning is a valuable tool in any dog trainer’s toolkit, and its benefits are well worth the investment of time and effort.

Checkout this video featuring Sarah Owings, a certified dog trainer and behaviour consultant. In this episode, Sarah will share her expertise on the benefits of errorless learning and provide tips for successful implementation. You will learn the basics of errorless learning, common mistakes to avoid, and practical strategies for teaching your dog new behaviours.

Whether you are a beginner or an experienced trainer, this video is sure to provide valuable insights and actionable advice for improving your training skills. So sit back, relax, and get ready to learn from one of the top experts in the field of dog training and behaviour.